Everyone thinks
that the consciousness in one
person is different from the consciousness in another person. No one can
measure consciousness, and say that it is confined to this or that person, or
that it starts here and stops there. Therefore people who say our souls are
different cannot prove existence of the individual soul. When the self is
neither the waking entity not the self is dream entity but the self is the formless
soul, which witnesses the coming and going of the three states. Different souls in the dram along with the
dream world becomes unreal when waking takes place similarly the when the
waking entity becomes aware of the fact that it itself is not the self in the
midst of waking experience than whatever sees ,known, believed and experienced of the waking world as waking entity becomes
falsehood.
People accept the reality of the idea of the individual soul, is because they cling to
this I as self, because they lack the humility to give up the ego, because they
don't understand that the ego(waking entity)
is not a permanent thing; the ego(waking entity) along with the waking
world dies in deep sleep.
Dualists’ sages could not distinguish between ‘I’
and ‘Formless Witness.’ The 'I' was the Formless Witness. His highest was the
Jiva. You are so much attached to the 'I' that you do not want to think that
'I' does not exist. Again you are unable to detach the ‘I’ from the Real Witness.
Dualist sages say: - If everything else is false,
your statement that you are Brahman is itself false. But when one says Nonduality
or Advaita is false, there must be the awareness, consciousness, behind the
very statement. They are unaware of the
fact that the formless soul, which witnesses the waking entity and waking world
together. They are basing themselves on the waking entity and waking worlds.
The three states are an object to the formless subject. When they are part of
the object (waking) , which they take it as real. Thus they are based on the
waking entity which is bound by birth, life, death and world whereas as the
soul is birthless, deathless and world less because it is formless. Thus
dualist is a theory based on the waking entity, which is based on birth, life,
death and rebirth which is false theory based on the false self and false
experience because the soul the innermost self is birthless and deathless
therefore the question of rebirth and reincarnation does not arise from the standpoint
of the formless soul, the innermost self.
